3 Mental fitness myths that keep us Stuck — Part 1
Before we begin, if you’re new here: welcome to Pepper. 🌶️
Pepper challenges the beliefs we have about our brains—the ones that sound helpful but quietly keep us stuck.
Because I don’t believe most of us have a motivation problem.
Or an information problem.
Or even a mindset problem.
I believe we have a mental fitness problem.
We know a lot. We think a lot. We intend to change.
But we rarely train our minds with the same consistency with which we train our bodies.
Here are three of the biggest mental fitness myths I had to unlearn.
Myth #1: “I need to feel motivated first”
“I’ll start tomorrow.”
I can’t tell you how many times I’ve said those words.
Tomorrow, I’ll exercise.
Tomorrow, I’ll eat better.
Tomorrow, I’ll write the article.
Tomorrow, I’ll launch the idea.
Tomorrow.
Tomorrow.
Tomorrow.
I wasn’t lazy. I wasn’t incapable.
I was waiting for something: motivation.
I believed I would wake up one morning feeling inspired, energised and completely ready to change my life.
That morning rarely came.
Then, one morning, Pepper and I were making coffee.
“I just don’t feel motivated today,” I said.
Pepper smiled. “Did you brush your teeth this morning?”
“Of course.”
“Were you motivated?”
“No.”
“Did you put on your seatbelt when you got into the car?”
“Yes.”
“Were you motivated?”
“No.”
“What about brushing your children’s teeth?”
I laughed. “Definitely not.”
Pepper smiled again.
“So why are you waiting for motivation before you train your mind?”
That question changed how I saw everything.
We give motivation far too much credit.
We admire motivated athletes, entrepreneurs and leaders. But the people who achieve extraordinary things aren’t motivated every day.
They’re consistent.
They show up when they feel like it—and when they don’t.
The difference isn’t motivation.
It’s repetition.
What neuroscience tells us (THE SCIENCE ->)
Your brain is designed to conserve energy.
New behaviours require conscious effort, so they often feel uncomfortable at first. But as you repeat an action, the brain becomes more efficient at performing it.
The behaviour gradually requires less thought and effort.
That’s how habits are formed.
Not because you suddenly feel motivated, but because you’ve practised the behaviour often enough for it to become easier and more automatic.
Your brain doesn’t only ask:
“Do I feel like doing this?”
It also relies on:
“What have I done repeatedly before?”
Myth #2: “Positive thinking will change my life”
“Just think positively.”
“Look on the bright side.”
“Everything happens for a reason.”
After one of the hardest periods of my life, I heard those words more times than I can count.
People meant well. They wanted to help.
But every time someone told me to “just think positively,” I felt as though I was failing.
Because I couldn’t.
Not after burnout.
Not after repeated loss.
Not after seven miscarriages.
Not on the days when getting out of bed already felt like a victory.
The problem wasn’t that I wasn’t trying hard enough.
The problem was that a positive thought alone couldn’t retrain the patterns my brain had spent years building.
Then Pepper handed me a tennis racket.
“Have you ever played tennis?” she asked.
“A little.”
“Close your eyes and imagine the perfect serve.”
So I did.
“Are you a better tennis player now?”
I laughed. “Of course not.”
Pepper smiled.
“Then why do you think confidence, calm or resilience work differently?”
Silence.
“You don’t build a skill by imagining it. You build it by practising it.”
What neuroscience tells us
The brain can adapt through experience—a capacity known as neuroplasticity.
But change requires more than one positive thought.
Repeated experiences and behaviours help strengthen the neural networks involved in those patterns. That’s why one breathing exercise won’t automatically make you calm, just as one workout won’t make you physically strong.
A positive thought can help you take the first step.
But it’s repeated action that helps build the pathway.
Hope matters.
Optimism matters.
Positive thinking can point you in the right direction.
But thinking isn’t the same as training.
Myth #3: “Knowing what to do is enough”
A few years ago, my bookshelf was full.
Books about habits.
Mindset.
Leadership.
Neuroscience.
Psychology.
I listened to podcasts, watched TED Talks and read countless articles.
I knew I should sleep more.
Move more.
Stress less.
Take breaks.
Put my phone away.
Be more present.
The strange part?
Knowing all of this didn’t change my life.
Pepper looked at my overflowing bookshelf and smiled.
“You don’t have an information problem.”
“You have a practice problem.”
Then she took me to a piano.
“Can you play?” she asked.
“Not really.”
She handed me a book about playing the piano.
“Read this.”
A few minutes later, she asked, “Can you play now?”
I laughed. “No. I would need to practise.”
“Exactly,” Pepper said. “So why do you expect your brain to work differently?”
What neuroscience tells us
Understanding something and being able to do it are not the same thing.
You can understand how to stay calm and still lose your patience.
You can know how to focus and still reach for your phone.
You can know how confidence works and still avoid the difficult conversation.
Information gives you awareness.
Practice builds the skill.
Reading a recipe doesn’t make you a chef.
Watching tennis doesn’t make you a player.
Reading about confidence doesn’t make you confident.
Somewhere along the way, we confused consuming information with creating transformation.
They’re not the same.
Knowledge informs.
Practice transforms.
Why I built Pepper
I didn’t create Pepper to give people more information.
We already have thousands of books, podcasts, courses and videos telling us what to do.
The problem isn’t a lack of knowledge.
The problem is turning what we know into something we can actually use—especially when life becomes difficult.
Small daily exercises designed to help you practise presence, calm, courage, confidence, resilience and the other mental muscles.
Some reps return again and again.
On purpose.
Because repetition isn’t a flaw in the method.
Repetition is the method.
You wouldn’t expect one push-up to transform your body.
So why would one breathing exercise, journal entry or courageous action transform your brain?
But hundreds of small reps?
That’s where change begins.
Your Pepper Rep for today
Don’t wait for motivation.
Don’t search for another positive quote.
Don’t learn something new.
Instead, practise one thing you already know:
Take one conscious breath.
Put your phone away for five minutes.
Pause before reacting.
Write one honest sentence.
Send the message you’ve been avoiding.
Take one small action your future self would be proud of.
Just one rep.
You’re not trying to change your entire life today.
You’re showing your brain what to practise next.
One last thought
Mental fitness shouldn’t be something we think about only when life falls apart.
It should be something we train every day—so we’re stronger when life gets hard.
You don’t need more motivation.
You don’t need to force yourself to think positively.
And you probably don’t need more information.
You need practice.
One small action.
Repeated often.
That’s how mental muscles grow.
🌶️ Train your brain. Or your brain trains you.
Comments